And who decides?
Remark for Scottish readers: Although I am based in Scotland, data from England is easier to source. The mental health demographics for Scotland are likely to be very similar for England, hence I believe the same observations apply.
In England, around one in five adults report symptoms of a common mental health problem, such as anxiety or depression, in any given week (Mind). NHS survey data put the figure at 22.6% of 16 to 64 year olds in 2023/24, and at more than a quarter (25.8%) of 16 to 24 year olds (reported in the BMJ). In any given week in England, Generalised Anxiety Disorder (GAD) comes top of the list, followed by PTSD, depression, phobias, OCD and panic disorder (Mind). Then we have more clinically severe conditions like bipolar, schizophrenia and psychosis. And we haven’t even started on neurodiversity, chronic fatigue, eating disorders and self harm.
Some will argue that the list includes presentations which aren’t necessarily mental health conditions. Others will point to there being too much diagnosis in recent years. But, who decides whether a condition is an aspect of someone’s mental health?
It hasn’t always been like this
Much of the language we use when describing mental health conditions is modern. Meaning the last 100 years or so, sometimes much more recently. Historically, mental health was driven partly by caring for troubled people and partly driven by society’s perception of what normality is. Hence homosexuality, single motherhood and certain political views were all treated as signs of an unsound mind (and still are in parts of the world). Left-handed people were instructed to use their right hands. People suffering psychosis, mania or schizophrenia were likely to have been treated for possessing evil spirits, although by the Victorian era there were “lunatic asylums” and, for those with learning difficulties there were “idiot asylums” for the “imbeciles”. Hard to imagine that today, particularly their use of language.
But the point is, that mental health has always been defined against a baseline of what society decided was a healthy normality.
Which is why conditions like obesity, addiction, rudeness, shyness, adultery, poor eating habits and debt are not considered to be mental health conditions. Not in isolation, anyway. However the charity Money and Mental Health does draw our attention to how people with mental health conditions can end up deep in debt.
Will a mental health diagnosis help me?
The usual advice, if you believe you have mental health issues, is to see your GP. In many cases, that will be as far as things will go. You will be prescribed anti-anxiety or anti-depressant medications, and they may or may not work. If they don’t work you will likely be prescribed a different medication, as there are many. For more serious conditions, like bipolar disorder (previously known as manic-depression owing to extreme swings between the two conditions) or psychosis you may well get to see a psychiatrist. Probably not straight away, and sometimes after a wait of many weeks or months. Rarely, you will be “sectioned” and taken to the local mental health hospital whether you want to or not. But that’s if you are at risk of harming yourself or others.
Will this route help you? Well, that all depends on what problem we are trying to solve. If your life circumstances are causing you to be unhealthily anxious, then medication may help reduce that anxiety. But so will a change in life circumstances. And this is where things get tricky. Because many of us can’t simply change their life circumstances. We may find a way out of an oppressive workplace or a controlling relationship. But will the consequences necessarily be better? Consequently many people take the meds and get on with life. Back in the 1970s my grandmother was prescribed Valium “for her nerves”. She spent all her life doing things for other people and some of those people seemed to take advantage of that. Did she have a mental health issue or was her mind and body reacting as they were designed to react when under stress?
Another reason for a mental health diagnosis is to obtain support. Either by way of social benefit payments. Or by way of allowances in their workplace or institution. Such as a student being allowed extra time in an exam. Some say this has gone too far. In England and Wales, the CSJ (a think tank) reports that as at July 2025, some 633,000 people are receiving PIP for anxiety and mood disorders. In the 16 to 24 age group, over 450,000 are receiving PIP, mostly for mental health conditions, with autism representing over one third of that total and ADHD brings it close to 50%. Easy to see why people want a positive diagnosis.
So the answer is?
I am not going to criticise anyone for using the PIP system for what it was designed for. I believe mental health conditions are real and that people suffer through having them. But the biggest problem I have is that our post-industrial society is designed for maximum efficiency and that means it’s designed to suit the needs of most of the people most of the time. The child who stares out of the window during lessons is described as inattentive and lazy. Nobody considers that they might feel anxious let alone helps them understand what’s going on for them. When I was young, dyslexia was poorly understood and dyslexic children were deemed to have learning difficulties. Fortunately, more consideration is given to such children these days.
In an ideal world, everyone will be able to negotiate the kind of life they need. In the environment that works for them. A child who can’t settle in a classroom is probably better served learning skills in a workshop or studio. The employee who is bullied at work would be more effective under a different manager or working for themselves. But our society simply doesn’t function like that. Not one that’s centrally controlled, anyway.
The endgame seems to be that with our direction of travel, we may find that most people will need to be on medication in order to perform in this society. We find that in England alone, 2025/26 estimates from the NHSBSA suggest, over 9 million people were prescribed anti-depressants. An NHS Survey of Mental Health and Wellbeing in 2023/24 revealed that around one in eight adults report taking psychiatric medication, with one in six adults receiving some kind of mental health treatment. A figure that’s rising. The same NHS survey revealed that among 16 to 74 year olds with significant symptoms, medication use roughly doubled between 2007 and 2023/24, from 19.6% to 38.4%, while therapy rose from 10.4% to 17.9%.
Take control
I have traits which some people suggest are autistic. But I have absolutely no intention of getting an official diagnosis. The idea of a neurotypical person telling me I am not normal is, frankly, patronising. I feel like saying: Have you considered getting a diagnosis for neurotypicalness? Sure, there are things I find hard. Like being in noisy crowds, trying to keep up with quickfire conversations where participants don’t finish their sentences, and being expected to react to indirect suggestions of what a person might want. But I am now confident enough to say: Can you repeat that please, using unambiguous language? Or: I need to be left alone to figure this out, stop trying to help me.
I’ve been fortunate in finding work that suits me, and I’m aware that not everyone has. Many people struggle to meet their daily needs, whether they have a mental health condition or not. But that doesn’t make us completely powerless.
I recognise that many people start from a position of powerlessness, and that my telling them to take control can sound like one more burden placed on the individual. But to begin to turn life around, I really would encourage people to take more control over their wellbeing. With the information that’s available these days, including AI, find out what the GP is prescribing you, what it does, and why. (Important remark: Don’t stop taking the meds, the point is to engage your GP in an informed conversation, not to simply rebel.) Find out what other options are available. Learn to ask for what you need. Don’t expect anyone else to understand you but take responsibility for understanding yourself. And, I am bound to say, speak to a therapist.
As a therapist myself, one of my favourite words is “empowerment”. I work with people relationally. My job isn’t necessarily to educate – that’s all too easily done with online resources anyway. But the missing part is how we might understand ourselves in a relationship. How we might be affecting those around us. And how we are affected by them (triggers). Therapy is rarely free and doesn’t often come cheap. But there are NHS services, workplace helplines, and charities out there for those unable to afford private therapy. And it could be the best investment you ever make.
Adrian Tupper is an Edinburgh based psychotherapist, counsellor and supervisor working privately at Space for Therapy and Eyre Place Osteopathic Practice. Visit adriantupper.co.uk for more information.